What building insurance should cover for a modern commercial property.

What Should Building Insurance Cover? A Complete Guide

Here in Illinois, we see our fair share of unpredictable weather, from powerful summer storms to freezing winters that can lead to burst pipes. These events are a stark reminder of how vulnerable our properties can be. While you can’t control the weather, you can control how prepared you are. Building insurance is your first line of defense, providing the funds to repair structural damage when you need it most. To be truly prepared, you need to know what should building insurance cover in these situations and more. This guide will help you understand your policy, identify potential gaps, and ensure your home is protected, no matter what the season brings.

Contact Us→

Key Takeaways

  • Insure for the Rebuild, Not the Resale: Base your coverage amount on the replacement cost—what it would take to reconstruct your building with today’s materials and labor—not its current market value.
  • Understand What Isn’t Covered: A standard policy has important limits. Be aware that major events like floods and gradual damage from wear and tear or pests are typically excluded and require separate planning or policies.
  • Strong Documentation Is Your Best Ally in a Claim: Keep detailed records before and after damage occurs. Photos, videos, and receipts provide clear evidence that helps streamline the claims process and supports your case if you need to appeal a decision.

What Is Building Insurance?

Think of your home or commercial property as one of your most significant assets. Building insurance is the policy that protects the physical structure of that asset. It’s designed to cover the cost of repairing or even completely rebuilding your property if it’s damaged or destroyed by a covered event. Whether you own a home, a condo, or a commercial space, this insurance is the foundation of your financial protection.

It’s easy to get confused by different insurance terms, but building insurance is straightforward: it’s all about the building itself. This includes the roof, walls, floors, and foundation, as well as permanent fixtures like plumbing and wiring. It’s the policy that steps in to handle the big, costly repairs after a disaster, ensuring you aren’t left with an overwhelming financial burden. At its core, building insurance provides the peace of mind that comes from knowing your investment is secure, no matter what happens.

Protecting Your Property’s Structure

Building insurance specifically covers the physical components of your property. This means if a storm damages your roof or a fire breaks out, your policy helps pay for the repairs. The coverage extends to the main building and often includes other structures on your property, like a detached garage, a shed, or even your fence.

It’s designed to protect you from a wide range of events, including fire, storm damage, theft, and vandalism. Imagine having to pay out-of-pocket to fix a collapsed wall or replace every window after a severe hailstorm. Building insurance is what stands between you and those potentially devastating costs, making sure you have the funds to restore your property to its original condition.

Securing Your Financial Investment

Beyond just paying for repairs, building insurance is about safeguarding your financial future. For most people, their property is their largest investment. This policy protects that investment from being wiped out by an unexpected disaster. Without it, you could face enormous costs to rebuild, potentially putting you in a difficult financial situation for years to come.

This coverage is crucial for homeowners, landlords, and business owners alike. It ensures that if your building is damaged, you can get back on your feet without draining your savings. Having the right insurance solutions in place provides security not just for your property, but for your overall financial well-being, allowing you to feel confident that your hard-earned investment is protected.

What Does Building Insurance Cover?

Think of building insurance as the financial shield for the physical structure of your property. It’s designed to cover the costs of repairing or even completely rebuilding your home or commercial space if it’s damaged by a covered event. This isn’t about the furniture, electronics, or personal belongings inside—that’s what contents insurance is for. Instead, building insurance focuses on the core components: the foundation, roof, walls, floors, and permanent fixtures like built-in cabinets, plumbing, and electrical systems.

When you face a major disaster, the last thing you want to worry about is how you’ll afford to fix your property. A solid building insurance policy steps in to handle those overwhelming expenses. The goal is to restore your property to the condition it was in before the damage occurred. Because every property is unique, from a historic home in Springfield to a modern office in East Peoria, it’s essential to have a policy that truly fits your needs. The right insurance services provide coverage that protects your investment and gives you a clear path forward after an unexpected event.

Fire and Smoke Damage

A fire can be one of the most devastating events a property owner can face. Building insurance is specifically designed to address this risk, covering the cost to repair or rebuild the structure of your property. This includes damage caused not just by the flames themselves, but also by the smoke and soot that can permeate walls, ceilings, and ventilation systems. Even a small fire can cause extensive smoke damage that requires professional cleaning and restoration. Your policy also typically covers damage from lightning strikes, which can cause fires or structural harm. This coverage is fundamental to ensuring you can recover from such a catastrophic event without facing financial ruin.

Theft and Vandalism

It’s unsettling to think about your property being intentionally damaged or broken into. Building insurance helps soften the financial blow from these malicious acts. If your property is vandalized with graffiti, broken windows, or other structural damage, your policy will help pay for the repairs. It also covers damage caused during a theft, such as a broken door frame or damaged walls. While the policy won’t cover the items stolen from inside the building, it ensures that the physical structure itself can be secured and restored. This coverage is crucial for protecting your property from the unpredictable actions of others and restoring your sense of security.

Weather-Related Damage

From powerful thunderstorms and hail to destructive winds, weather can take a serious toll on your property. Building insurance is your first line of defense against many of these events. It typically covers damage from storms, hail, wind, and other common weather-related incidents. For example, if a severe storm tears shingles off your roof or a fallen tree damages a wall, your policy would help cover the repair costs. It’s important to understand exactly which types of weather events are included, as some major natural disasters like floods and earthquakes often require separate coverage. You can always contact us to discuss the specific weather risks in our area.

Water Damage from Burst Pipes

A burst pipe can quickly cause significant damage to your floors, walls, and ceilings. This is a common issue, especially during cold winters when pipes are at risk of freezing. Building insurance generally covers the damage that results from a sudden and accidental water leak, like from a burst pipe or a faulty appliance hose. This means it will help pay to repair the water-damaged drywall, replace ruined flooring, and fix other structural issues caused by the leak. However, the policy usually doesn’t cover the cost of repairing the broken pipe itself. This distinction is key for understanding how your coverage works in a water damage scenario.

What Isn’t Covered by Building Insurance?

It’s a common misconception that building insurance provides blanket coverage for any and all types of damage. In reality, while your policy is a powerful tool for protecting your investment, it has specific limitations. Insurance is designed to cover sudden and accidental events, not predictable issues that arise over time or major catastrophes that require their own specialized policies.

Understanding these exclusions is just as important as knowing what your policy covers. It helps you see the full picture of your protection, identify any potential gaps, and plan accordingly. Whether that means setting aside a budget for routine upkeep or looking into supplemental coverage, being informed is the best way to avoid surprises down the road. Let’s walk through some of the most common things that a standard building insurance policy won’t cover.

Flood and Earthquake Damage

One of the most significant exclusions in standard building insurance policies is damage from floods and earthquakes. While your policy will likely cover water damage from a burst pipe inside your home, it won’t cover damage from rising water caused by heavy rains or an overflowing river. Similarly, any structural damage from earth movement, such as an earthquake, is typically excluded. These types of large-scale natural disasters require separate, specialized insurance policies to ensure you’re protected.

General Wear and Tear

Building insurance is there for unexpected damage, not the inevitable effects of aging. Any damage that results from general wear and tear or a lack of routine upkeep is considered the property owner’s responsibility. This includes things like a roof that needs replacing after reaching the end of its lifespan, paint that has started to peel, or plumbing fixtures that have worn out from use. Insurance providers view these as predictable costs of home maintenance, not sudden losses. Staying on top of regular maintenance is the best way to prevent small issues from turning into major, uninsured problems.

Pest and Rodent Damage

Similar to wear and tear, damage caused by pests like termites, insects, or rodents is almost always excluded from building insurance coverage. An infestation is considered a preventable maintenance issue that should be addressed before it causes significant harm. For example, if termites compromise the structural integrity of your building’s foundation or squirrels chew through electrical wiring, the cost of those repairs will likely fall to you. The best defense is a good offense, so be sure to schedule regular pest inspections to catch any potential problems early.

Intentional Damage

This one might seem straightforward, but it’s a critical exclusion to understand. Your building insurance policy will not cover any damage that you or another resident of the property causes on purpose. Insurance is designed to protect you from unforeseen accidents, and intentionally damaging your own property to file a claim is considered insurance fraud. This exclusion protects insurers and, by extension, all other policyholders from the costs associated with fraudulent claims, which helps keep premiums fair for everyone.

How Much Building Insurance Do You Need?

Figuring out the right amount of building insurance can feel like a guessing game, but it’s one of the most important decisions you’ll make to protect your property. The goal is to have enough coverage to completely rebuild if the worst happens, without paying for more than you need. If you’re underinsured, you could be left with a significant financial gap after a disaster. On the other hand, if you’re overinsured, you’re spending extra money every month that could be used elsewhere.

Getting this number right isn’t about looking up your property’s sale price online. It’s about calculating the true cost to reconstruct the building from the ground up. This includes everything from materials and labor to demolition and debris removal. Several key factors come into play, including the difference between what your property is worth on the market and what it costs to rebuild, the impact of local regulations, and the ever-changing costs of construction. Understanding these elements will help you secure the right protection for your home or business. Let’s walk through how to determine the right coverage for your property so you can have confidence in your policy.

Replacement Cost vs. Market Value: What’s the Difference?

One of the most common points of confusion when buying building insurance is the difference between replacement cost and market value. It’s a critical distinction. Market value is what your property, including the land, would sell for today. It’s influenced by things like location, school districts, and the current housing market.

Replacement cost, however, is the estimated cost to rebuild your property’s structure exactly as it was, using similar materials and quality. Building insurance is based on this rebuild cost, not the market value. Think of it this way: if your building is destroyed, the land is still there. Your insurance needs to cover the price of reconstructing the building on that land, which is a completely different calculation than its sale price.

Accounting for Local Building Codes

When you rebuild a property, you can’t always put it back exactly the way it was. You have to follow current local building codes, which may have changed since your property was originally constructed. These updated standards can add significant costs to your rebuild, requiring different materials or construction methods for safety and compliance.

A comprehensive insurance policy should account for these potential expenses. When calculating your coverage needs, remember to include costs for demolition of the old structure, debris removal, new materials, labor, and fees for professionals like architects or engineers. These are all part of the true cost of rebuilding, and overlooking them can leave you underinsured. We can help you find a policy that includes an ordinance or law coverage endorsement to handle these specific costs.

Factoring in Inflation and Material Costs

The cost of building materials and labor isn’t static; it changes over time due to inflation and supply and demand. The price of lumber, roofing, and other essential materials can fluctuate significantly from one year to the next. A coverage amount that was sufficient five years ago might fall short of today’s rebuilding costs. That’s why it’s so important to review your policy regularly.

The amount of coverage you need also depends on your property’s specific details, like its location, size, age, and the materials it’s made from. To get the most accurate estimate, it’s a great idea to work with a professional, like a contractor or appraiser. They can provide a detailed assessment of your property’s rebuild cost, helping you avoid being over or underinsured. For personalized guidance, you can always contact our team to review your coverage.

Building vs. Contents Insurance: What’s the Difference?

When you think about protecting your home, you might lump everything together under one big “home insurance” umbrella. But it’s actually a bit more specific than that. Two key types of coverage you’ll hear about are building insurance and contents insurance. Knowing the difference is crucial because it ensures that both your house itself and the treasured belongings inside are properly protected. Let’s break down what each one covers so you can feel confident you have the right protection.

Protecting the Structure vs. Your Personal Items

Think of it this way: if you could pick up your house and shake it, everything that stays put would be covered by building insurance. This includes the physical structure—the roof, walls, and floors—as well as permanent fixtures like your kitchen cabinets, bathroom sinks, and even your garage or garden shed. It’s designed to cover the cost of repairing or rebuilding your home if it’s damaged by an event like a fire or a major storm.

On the other hand, contents insurance covers all the things that would fall out—your furniture, electronics, clothes, and kitchenware. These are your personal belongings. This type of policy helps you replace these items if they’re stolen or damaged. Having the right home insurance means making sure both of these areas are covered.

Understanding Where Coverage Overlaps

It’s a common mistake to assume a standard policy covers everything you own against every possible risk. The reality is, there can be gray areas. For example, are fitted carpets part of the building or are they contents? What about your new dishwasher? This is where things can get confusing and leave you with unexpected gaps in your coverage.

To simplify things, many insurance providers offer combined home and contents policies. This bundles both types of protection into one plan, which helps prevent gaps in your coverage. The best way to make sure you’re fully protected is to review your policy details carefully. If you have any questions about what’s covered, it’s always a good idea to talk with an expert who can walk you through your options.

Debunking Common Building Insurance Myths

Insurance can feel complicated, and it’s easy to make assumptions about what your policy covers. Unfortunately, some of the most common beliefs about building insurance are actually myths that can leave you unprotected when you need it most. Believing your coverage is more comprehensive than it is can lead to major financial setbacks after an unexpected event. That’s why it’s so important to have a clear picture of what your policy does—and doesn’t—include. Let’s clear up a few of the biggest misconceptions so you can feel confident that your property has the right protection. We’ll walk through what’s true, what’s not, and what you can do about it.

Myth: All natural disasters are covered.

This is one of the most common and costly misunderstandings. Many people assume their standard building insurance policy is a catch-all for any act of nature, but that’s rarely the case. Most policies specifically exclude certain events, most notably floods and earthquakes. Here in Illinois, flooding can be a real concern, and you’ll need a separate policy to protect your property from that specific risk. It’s essential to read your policy documents carefully to understand the limitations of their policies. Don’t wait until after a disaster to discover a gap in your coverage. If you’re in a high-risk area, talk to your agent about adding the right protection.

Myth: The age of your building doesn’t matter.

It might seem like a building is a building, but from an insurer’s perspective, age is a huge factor. Older properties often come with higher risks. Think outdated electrical wiring, old plumbing, or a roof that’s seen better days. These elements can increase the likelihood of fires or water damage. Because of this, insurers often assess the condition and age of a property when setting premiums and determining what they’re willing to cover. You might face higher rates or find that certain types of damage related to wear and tear aren’t covered at all. Keeping your property well-maintained and updating key systems can help manage these costs and ensure you have solid coverage.

Myth: Your tenant’s policy covers your property.

If you’re a landlord, this is a critical distinction to understand. Many landlords mistakenly believe that because their tenant has renters insurance, their building is protected. This isn’t true. A tenant’s renters insurance is designed to cover their personal belongings—like furniture, electronics, and clothing—and provide them with liability protection. It does absolutely nothing to cover the physical structure of your building. If a fire damages the walls or a pipe bursts, their policy won’t pay for the repairs. To protect your investment, you need your own landlord or building insurance. It’s the only way to ensure the structure itself is covered.

How to Choose the Right Building Insurance Policy

Picking the right building insurance policy can feel like a huge task, but it doesn’t have to be. When you break it down, it’s all about matching your coverage to your specific property and financial situation. It’s tempting to just look for the lowest price, but the cheapest policy isn’t always the best one. A policy that doesn’t fully protect you can leave you with massive out-of-pocket expenses when you need support the most.

The key is to understand what you’re buying. You’ll want to look closely at the policy’s coverage limits, the type of protection it offers, and how much you’ll be responsible for paying in the event of a claim. It’s also important to consider any unique risks your property might face. By focusing on a few core components—coverage types, deductibles, and optional add-ons—you can confidently select a plan that provides real security. We can help you explore all the insurance solutions available to find the perfect fit for your needs.

Review Coverage Limits and Policy Types

First, let’s talk about policy types. Some policies only cover specific events listed in the document, which are known as “named peril” policies. Others, called “all-risk” policies, cover everything unless a peril is specifically excluded. An all-risk policy generally offers broader protection. It’s also crucial to understand that building insurance is based on the rebuild cost, not the market value. The market value is what your property would sell for, including the land. The rebuild cost is what it would actually take to reconstruct the building from the ground up. You want your policy to cover the rebuild cost to ensure you can fully restore your property after a major loss.

Understand Your Deductible and Liability

Your deductible is the amount you agree to pay out of pocket before your insurance coverage begins. Choosing a higher deductible can often make your regular premium cheaper, which is a nice perk for your budget. However, you need to be realistic. Make sure you can comfortably afford to pay that deductible if something happens. You don’t want to be in a position where you can’t even start repairs. At the same time, you need enough liability coverage. This protects you financially if someone gets injured on your property and decides to sue. Sufficient liability coverage is essential for safeguarding your personal assets from a potentially costly lawsuit.

Consider Optional Add-Ons (Riders)

A standard building insurance policy provides a solid foundation, but it doesn’t cover everything. For specific risks, you might need to add extra coverage, often called riders or endorsements. For example, most standard policies exclude damage from floods or earthquakes. If your property is in an area prone to these events, adding a rider for that specific risk is a smart move. While these add-ons will increase your premium, they provide critical protection that could save you from financial disaster. Not sure what risks your property faces? We can help you figure out if any riders make sense for you when you contact us for a personalized review.

How to File a Claim Effectively

Dealing with property damage is stressful enough without the added confusion of filing an insurance claim. The good news is that the process is straightforward when you know what to expect. Taking the right steps from the beginning can make a huge difference in getting your property—and your life—back to normal as quickly as possible. Think of it as a clear path forward, and we’re here to guide you every step of the way.

The key is to be prepared, organized, and proactive. When you’re facing repairs and potential displacement, the last thing you want is a complicated claims process. By understanding what information is needed and who you’ll be working with, you can move through each stage with confidence. This isn’t just about paperwork; it’s about making sure your claim accurately reflects your loss so you can get the support you need. Let’s walk through what to do immediately after damage occurs, how to document everything properly, and what to expect when working with your insurance adjuster.

What to Do Immediately After Damage Occurs

Before you even think about insurance, your first priority is safety. Make sure you and your family are out of harm’s way and address any immediate dangers, like turning off the main water valve after a pipe bursts or leaving the property if there’s a structural concern. Once the situation is secure, it’s time to act. You should contact us as soon as possible to start the claims process. The sooner you report the damage, the sooner we can begin helping you. It’s also wise to take steps to prevent further damage, like covering a hole in the roof with a tarp, but don’t make any permanent repairs until you’ve spoken with us.

Documenting Everything for Your Claim

This step is crucial. Thoroughly documenting the damage is the best way to support your claim. Grab your phone and take as many photos and videos as you can, capturing the damage from different angles and distances. Make a detailed list of all damaged items, including their estimated value and age, if possible. If you have to make temporary repairs or spend money on lodging because your home is uninhabitable, keep every single receipt. This detailed record will be essential for your adjuster and helps ensure you receive fair compensation for your loss. Creating a home inventory ahead of time can make this process even easier.

Working with Your Insurance Adjuster

After you file a claim, an insurance adjuster will be assigned to your case. Their job is to inspect the damage, investigate the cause, and determine the value of your loss based on your policy. Your adjuster will contact you to schedule a visit and discuss the next steps. It’s a good idea to be present during their inspection so you can point out all the damage you’ve documented and answer any questions they might have. Have your photos, videos, and expense records ready for them to review. Think of your adjuster as your main point of contact—they are there to assess the situation and help move your claim forward.

What to Do If Your Claim Is Denied

Receiving a denial letter for your building insurance claim is frustrating, especially when you’re already dealing with the stress of property damage. But it’s important to know that a denial isn’t always the final word. You often have the right to appeal the decision. The key is to understand why your claim was denied in the first place and what steps you can take to challenge it effectively.

Understanding Why Claims Get Denied

Your first step is to understand exactly what went wrong. Insurance claims can be denied for many reasons, and they aren’t always as complicated as you might think. Sometimes, the issue is a simple administrative oversight, like missing paperwork or not providing enough detail in your initial report. Other times, it comes down to a misunderstanding of your policy’s coverage—for example, your policy might not cover the specific type of damage your building sustained.

Some of the most common mistakes homeowners make include failing to document the damage thoroughly or making repairs before an adjuster has assessed the property. Pinpointing the exact reason for the denial is crucial because it will guide your next steps.

The Appeal Process: Your Next Steps

Once you know why your claim was denied, you can begin the appeal process. Your first move should be to contact your insurance provider and ask for a detailed explanation in writing. This gives you a clear understanding of their reasoning. From there, you can start gathering additional evidence to support your case, which might include more detailed photos, contractor estimates, or witness statements.

When you’re ready, you can formally appeal the decision by submitting your new documentation. If the process feels overwhelming, you might consider working with a public adjuster who can help document the damage and negotiate on your behalf. Remember, you have the right to question the decision and provide more information.

Related Articles

Contact Us→

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is my building insurance coverage amount different from my property’s market value? This is a great question because it gets to the heart of what building insurance is for. Your policy is designed to cover the replacement cost—the actual price of materials and labor needed to rebuild your property from the ground up. Market value, on the other hand, is the price your property would sell for, which includes factors like land value, location, and school districts. Insurance doesn’t cover the land because it will still be there after a disaster, so the focus is purely on the cost of reconstruction.

Is building insurance the same thing as homeowners insurance? Think of homeowners insurance as a package deal. It typically includes three main parts: building insurance to protect the structure, contents insurance for your personal belongings, and liability coverage in case someone is injured on your property. So, while building insurance isn’t the same as homeowners insurance, it’s a critical component of it. If you own a home, your policy will almost always include building coverage.

My policy says it covers water damage, so why wouldn’t it cover a flood? This is a common point of confusion. Standard building insurance policies cover sudden and accidental water damage that originates from inside your property, like a burst pipe or a faulty washing machine hose. Flood damage, however, refers to water from a natural source—like an overflowing river or heavy rainfall—that enters your home from the outside. This type of event requires a separate, dedicated flood insurance policy.

I’m a landlord. Isn’t my tenant’s renters insurance enough to cover the property? No, and this is a crucial distinction for any property owner. Your tenant’s renters insurance is designed to protect their personal belongings, like furniture and electronics, and to provide them with liability coverage. It offers absolutely no protection for the physical structure of your building. As the owner, you are responsible for insuring the building itself with a proper landlord or building insurance policy.

What’s the single most important thing I can do to make the claims process smoother? Without a doubt, it’s documentation. As soon as it’s safe to do so after damage occurs, take as many photos and videos as you can from various angles. A detailed visual record of the damage before you start cleaning up or making temporary fixes is the most powerful tool you have. It provides clear evidence for your adjuster and helps ensure your claim accurately reflects the full extent of your loss.

Feld Insurance logo in blue and white representing trusted insurance services.

PROTECT YOUR HOUSE, CAR, FAMILY AND MORE

Our Agents Make a Difference! Get Quote Now!

Best Time to Contact